The taste of the sandwiches are great. I've had most of them. My problem has always been with the amount of filler compared to the actual protein in their sandwiches.

Their advertised images show sandwiches chock full of protein but when the ad becomes reality -- you are staring at lettuce. Not to mention that the meat and cheese stops a full inch from both sides of the sandwich.

If this isn't false advertisement, I genuinely don't know what IS false advertisement.

Staff is always super friendly and good at their jobs. I'm guessing that ownership is looking to crank out profit by skimping on the actual product.

Bottom line, for 20 bucks, you shouldn't be eating mostly free lettuce.

This review is for their catering service, as we hired Good Behaviour through our wedding caterer, Enville Catering (located across the street). They brought them in to serve ice cream doughnuts, which is a menu item no longer available in stores—so we were thrilled to be able to offer this unique treat at our own wedding.

I first tried Good Behaviour ice cream several years ago at their pop-up in Kensington Market, and when sampling flavours recently during our wedding tasting, I immediately noticed the improvements in flavour, texture, and consistency – kudos to the hard work they’ve put into refining their recipes! As a Cantonese couple, we were especially excited about their Chinese-inspired flavours, like Hong Kong milk tea and black sesame. The Hong Kong milk tea was perfectly balanced, with the tea complementing the creamy milk, and the black sesame was rich, velvety, and superior to any other black sesame ice cream I’ve tried.

Our guests absolutely loved having their ice cream doughnuts at our wedding and we will definitely continue to support them by buying pints whenever we pass by. Highly recommend them!

For me, the ice cream definitely outshines the sandwiches here. The Torta della Nonna is easily one of my favourite ice cream flavours there. It is rich, balanced, and just so good. I also tried the coffee crème brûlée, which was delicious as well, though a touch on the sweeter side. The other flavours like Dragon Poop, cookies and crème, s’mores, and birthday cake didn’t blow me away but they have a good variety. Something for everyone!

I finally got around to trying Good Behaviour Ice Cream after hearing so many people talk about it. Overall, it was a good experience, but honestly, I didn’t find anything that really stood out as special or unforgettable.

First off, the location is great — super easy to get to, and the outdoor seating area is such a nice touch, especially in the summer. It’s a great spot to hang out with friends or just enjoy a cone on a warm evening. The vibe is fun and welcoming, and it definitely has that local neighborhood feel that makes you want to support them.

They have a pretty big variety of flavors, which I always appreciate. There’s something for everyone, and it’s clear they put effort into offering interesting options beyond the usual basics. That said, while the flavors were good, none of them really wowed me or made me feel like I had discovered something amazing.

When you’re paying a premium price for ice cream, you expect that extra punch — whether it’s ultra-creamy texture, bold and unique flavors, or just something memorable that makes you crave it again. For me, Good Behaviour just didn’t quite hit that mark. Everything tasted fine, but nothing really blew me away.

That being said, I still enjoyed my visit. The staff were friendly, the atmosphere was nice, and the overall experience was pleasant. I’d definitely go back if I’m nearby or already in the area, but I don’t think I’d go out of my way or make a special trip just for this ice cream.

All in all, it’s a solid spot, especially if you’re looking for a fun summer hangout or want to try a few new flavors. Just don’t go in expecting to be completely blown away, and you’ll have a good time.

Sooooo good! Took an Uber down from Richmond Hill to walk around this neighborhood and visit some breweries, and stopped here first for lunch. Couldn’t have been more happy with this place! Tried both the ice cream and the sandwiches. Tiramisu ice cream delivered and tastes just like eating Tiramisu. And the Classic cold sub was exactly what I hoped for. Solid Italian sub. Generous portion. My husband got the hot meatball sub and is still talking about how good it was, especially the pesto mayo. They are a well-oiled machine here. Service was friendly, but really efficient. Clearly know what they are doing. Would definitely come back here and would recommend. Thank you so much!

Great first experience. I debated between the hot and cold but ultimately decided on the hot meatball sub and was delicious. Coming from an Italian, im typically picky about the tomato sauce and taste of the meatballs but wasn't disappointed. Their ice cream flavours are unique and would highly recommend trying. Will be back!

Have tried twice this week, both times pickup to have at home. No seating except a few benches outside, cute order window and inside some frozen (biscuits, pizza, icecream, dumplings) and pantry items such as chili sauces, chips. Star of the show is their sub sandwiches. Soft sesame roll (not crusty-hard-rip-off-the-roof-of/your-mouth bread) stuffed with freshest ingredients for the hot and cold subs. Classic Italian cured meat sub 10/10, Caprese 10/10, Spicy Meatball 11/10, Pork Shoulder 11/10. The juicy meatballs: combination of pork, veal and beef, are cooked till tender and meaty, not full of breadcrumbs or mealy textured. The pork shoulder with collard greens and rapini, have amazing flavour. All hot sandwiches come topped with melted provolone cheese. Each bite is like a big warm hug and it loves you back! Good value too for the size and quality. Will be back to try their other sandwiches.
For dessert, they make wonderful ice cream in lots of drool-worthy flavours. Sold in takeaway pints or by the scoop in cups or cones. So happy to have Good Behaviour so close in my neighbourhood. I can’t wait to go back! One of the best sandwich spots in Toronto!

Excellent sandwiches. Worth the walk to experience. Also have ice cream and dessert options. We shared 2 sandwiches. Spiced meatball and a brisket.

So good! The meatball sub was outstanding! Friendly service and delicious ice cream. This location is a welcomed addition to our east end neighborhood.

Found this place on BlogTO and it was great! Easy parking on the street, friendly staff, and a down-to-earth vibe. I loved that they had several local brands to grocery shop from without being overwhelming. Their ice cream flavours unique and flavourful. I tried the matcha cookies and cream and it was so rich and delicous! I also loved their submarine sandwiches! I tried the classic one and it was great! Also loved their decor and open/garage style window. Great for a lunch/dinner sandwich or ice cream treat. I'll go again if in the neighbourhood.

We have been to this amazing little shop twice in the last couple of weeks and I have to spread the word about how great they are!!
The first time we went there we both got 2 scoops on waffle cones - I had a French Vanilla and a really tasty flavour that I forget what it was called - something like Torte Nona, and my wife had peanut butter chocolate and Hazelnut I believe.
When we got home we discovered that we had unfortunately been charged twice on our debit card so I called up the shop and they told me that they would refund me right away.
Because it was a debit card however, they couldn't do it so they offered to just hold the credit until next time, which I was more than happy with as we knew that we would be returning soon!
A week or so later we went back and this time I had the Torte Nona with a scoop of Coconut Cream Pie and my wife tried that too and loved it with the chocolate peanut butter again.
What a great treat on such a hot day walking our doggie.
Both times we have gone there, they have been incredibly busy preparing sandwiches for people and we saw the sandwich menu and are going to have to try that sometime soon as they looked big and delicious!!
Definitely check them out if you are in the area!!