the staff here were so incredibly kind, friendly, and approachable , this is a very good place for families. the chicken parm sandwich was solid , but i might have been expecting a bit more. there was a generous amount of melted, super stringy SLABS of mozzarella which i enjoyed, and the freshness and slight crunch of the soft bread was also great, but the “vodka” sauce was a bit too marinara-like for me — i don’t LOVE the sweetness of the tomato sauce. also, the sandwich completely was completely DRENCHED with the sauce , which would usually be a good thing but it made the texture of the really great bread very soggy. the chicken was good though — a bit thin , but there were two stacked and they weren’t dry at all.

you can also watch them make donuts while you eat which is fun !!

the staff here were so incredibly kind, friendly, and approachable , this is a very good place for families. the chicken parm sandwich was solid , but i might have been expecting a bit more. there was a generous amount of melted, super stringy SLABS of mozzarella which i enjoyed, and the freshness and slight crunch of the soft bread was also great, but the “vodka” sauce was a bit too marinara-like for me — i don’t LOVE the sweetness of the tomato sauce. also, the sandwich completely was completely DRENCHED with the sauce , which would usually be a good thing but it made the texture of the really great bread very soggy. the chicken was good though — a bit thin , but there were two stacked and they weren’t dry at all.

you can also watch them make donuts while you eat which is fun !!

Yummmmmm!!!!
We ordered the Margherita and Sausage and Onion pizza. Staff are warm and welcoming, very attentive and considerate to my kid's allergies
Overall a very good experience since we are all dying of hunger and they saved our lives!! 10 out of 5 stars

I've been going here for donuts for a while now (my favourite!!) but have never had the food until today. HIGHLY recommend oh my goodness. We shared an order of breadsticks which were so good. Fantastic marinara sauce 👌 We also split an American Hero sandwich, which was outstanding. The ingredients were super fresh & the meat was incredible quality. We got a pizza & mozzarella sticks to go and I'm so excited so dig in!! And of course, a half dozen donuts. Finally, the staff are so friendly, excellent service and great seats for window watching.

I think this is some of the best pizza I've had in the city! Mozza sticks we're also solid, as far as mozza sticks go. Cheese pizza was great, and the mushroom one with the white base was delicious (and I'm not normally into non-tomato base pizza).

I think this is some of the best pizza I've had in the city! Mozza sticks we're also solid, as far as mozza sticks go. Cheese pizza was great, and the mushroom one with the white base was delicious (and I'm not normally into non-tomato base pizza).

This restaurant was highly recommended to us for their sandwiches and donuts...but we decided to go for pizza. I rarely order pizza from restaurants that are not strictly gluten free, but I did here and highly recommend it. Staff seemed to be well versed in proper protocols to ensure a gf pizza..and it was delicious!

Ordered the cheese pizza slice here for CAD7 and it was really good. Fast, fresh and crispy crust. Really good flavor. No complaints. Good job! They also sell donuts here, I saw them packing a really really large order.... had to have been like more than a dozen boxes of more than a dozen in each which just shows how good they are. They also have an old school vibe to the shop. It's not overly decorated or anything it feels like a humble diner which i really liked as well.

Ordered the cheese pizza slice here for CAD7 and it was really good. Fast, fresh and crispy crust. Really good flavor. No complaints. Good job! They also sell donuts here, I saw them packing a really really large order.... had to have been like more than a dozen boxes of more than a dozen in each which just shows how good they are. They also have an old school vibe to the shop. It's not overly decorated or anything it feels like a humble diner which i really liked as well.

I had The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizza on my must-try list for a while, and I’m really glad I finally got the chance to stop by. Although the wait was a bit long, it was absolutely worth it.
The service was solid, the prices were fair, and the portions were generous. We ordered two of their specials, which came with a Caesar salad, an 18” pizza, and 6 donuts each — and we had more than enough leftovers for the next day.
If you're planning your next food stop in Toronto, I highly recommend adding this spot to your list. And whatever you do, don’t skip the donuts — they’re incredible! I’m from Ottawa, and I regularly make a detour to Farm Boy just to pick up Harry & Heels donuts. So discovering them here was a real bonus.
Well done to the team — I’ll definitely be back!

I had The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizza on my must-try list for a while, and I’m really glad I finally got the chance to stop by. Although the wait was a bit long, it was absolutely worth it.
The service was solid, the prices were fair, and the portions were generous. We ordered two of their specials, which came with a Caesar salad, an 18” pizza, and 6 donuts each — and we had more than enough leftovers for the next day.
If you're planning your next food stop in Toronto, I highly recommend adding this spot to your list. And whatever you do, don’t skip the donuts — they’re incredible! I’m from Ottawa, and I regularly make a detour to Farm Boy just to pick up Harry & Heels donuts. So discovering them here was a real bonus.
Well done to the team — I’ll definitely be back!

The overall exp was not too good, service was poor, had to ask for same thing multiple times, water served was not clean and every time glass was untidy each time. Pizza was ok on taste not that good but service was poor. Patio is good, interiors are mediocre and very closely placed.
Had to ask for chilly flakes which never came to the table, still gave the tip to the server but no thank you, acknowledgement. Not recommended if you are looking for a pleasing experience and ambience.
Can try other cafes, multiple available on the street with better services

Such a gem to eat at! My fiancé and I absolutely love this place! The margarita pizza and mozzarella sticks are always a hit for us here. The donuts are always fresh and fluffy too! Would definitely recommend it if you’re visiting Toronto.

Visited after reading the positive online reviews. It's very good pizza compared to "hot and ready" fast food chains, but not pizza Elysium. It's definitely above average, that's it. Friendly staff, quaint atmosphere, decent pizza. Oh btw, they make homemade donuts. Didn't try them but they looked yummy.

Our 41st anniversary weekend in Toronto. Fourth Man on Fire was highly recommended for great pizza. I called at 630pm to see if we needed a reservation. No you don’t we have tables available, I said where we were staying and we’d Uber over right away. 20 minutes later we arrive and they told they had no pizza dough for eat in and the restaurant was closing. We could get take out. You have dough for take out but not eat in? We left and went to a fabulous Italian restaurant down the street.

I had an amazing experience at The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria! The food was absolutely delicious from start to finish.

Really impressed with this place! Started with the mozzarella sticks—crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside, just perfect. I had a half-and-half pizza (pepperoni & mushrooms on one side, mushrooms & black olives on the other), and both were packed with flavor. The crust was light and delicious, and the toppings were fresh and generous.

Finished off with an apple fritter donut and a cookies & cream donut—both were sweet, soft, and super satisfying. Everything was on point. Definitely a 5/5 experience!

I’d heard about Fourth Man in the Fire for years—especially when Ryan Reynolds name-dropped it while talking about his Toronto roots. Naturally, it shot to the top of my “must-try” list.

Finally made the trip, and I have to say, the pizza dough lives up to the hype. Thin, crispy, with just the right chew—it’s the kind of base that holds its own. I ordered the Margherita, my usual benchmark for any new pizza spot. While I wasn’t blown away by the toppings, the dough definitely carried the show.

The space has that classic, no-fuss vibe, and service was quick. If you're into solid, New York-style slices and value a good crust, it’s absolutely worth checking out.

They just have it all!!! Before you even sit down, you’re greeted with a smile and a wave of kindness from all members of the team. We had the caesar salad and mozzarella sticks to start - which both hit the spot. The pizza was flavourful, fresh and crust was perfect crispness. On the car ride home after leaving the restaurant, my heart and belly were so happily full. Can’t wait to come back again already

First time visiting this place, and it turned out to be a great spot to enjoy pizza with a group of friends. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the food was delicious. The pizza had a perfect balance of flavors, with fresh ingredients and a crispy crust. Definitely a place worth coming back to!