The pizzas looked good, but the service left such a poor impression that I will not return to try them.

There were two of us, and when we asked to move to a smaller table to leave the four-person table available for a larger group, the server responded with attitude. Once it became clear that we only wanted donuts, we were not offered a menu and felt largely ignored. You sell both pizza and donuts—customers buying dessert should still feel welcome.

We bought two donuts and seated ourselves. The server repeatedly checked on nearby tables but never once asked whether we needed anything or even acknowledged us. All I wanted was basic politeness and a complimentary cup of tap water. The difference in attention made me feel that a smaller order, and perhaps a smaller potential tip, meant we were not worth serving.

Unfortunately, the donuts were overwhelmingly sweet and unpleasant to eat. Combined with the selective greetings and uncomfortable lack of acknowledgement, the whole visit felt unwelcoming.

I cannot judge the pizza because I did not try it. But good food alone would not make me return after this experience. Basic courtesy should be offered to every customer, regardless of what they spend or whether a tip is involved.

I was extremely disappointed with my experience. When we first arrived, we were completely ignored and had to wait before anyone acknowledged us. Unfortunately, the service did not improve from there.

I ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza, but there were barely any mushrooms on it. For a pizza that cost nearly $40, I expected much better quality and attention to detail.

The staff also need to improve their customer service. They should be more courteous, patient, and attentive when taking orders. There appeared to be a language barrier, and instead of understanding the order clearly at the beginning, there was a lot of back-and-forth and repeated trips to the kitchen to ask if certain requests could be done. This made the entire ordering process feel frustrating and unorganized.

Throughout the entire meal, nobody came back to check on us, ask if we needed anything else, or see how our food was. Basic table service was missing. To make matters worse, our wine was served without wine glasses, and we were not provided with water glasses — something that should be standard when dining in.

Overall, the experience did not come close to matching the price. The food lacked the quality expected, and the service needs significant improvement. Better communication, attention to customers, and basic hospitality would make a big difference.

1st visit: Wow. Amazing donuts!
My friend and I were just walking by this place and noticed the display of goodies inside and couldn’t resist.

Original dipped in choco & Hawaiian cream 👌🏻

2nd visit: came back here for pizza AND donuts this time and wow… The Caesar wasn’t heavy with creamy dressing, it was crispy, light and just with the right amount of bacon, cheese and croutons. Kudos! The pizza was massive, came out steaming hot and it was hard to resist the urge to dig right in. The crust was perfect, even for someone like me who doesn’t like pizza crust. It was saucy without being sloppy and perfect combo was pepperoni, mushrooms and cheese. The donut select was great, except there was only one sour cream glazed left which was bought by a gentleman who lined up before me. I’ll have to go back another time to try it next time. This time we got a Hawaiian & Tiramisu and they were both excellent. 🥰

Stopped in for a quick slice. Really simple menu with only three options if you're grabbing slices. We got a pepperoni slice and it was HOT when we got it. The pizza was delicious and I really liked the texture of the crust. It's a little bit firmer and had a bit of crisp to it while also feeling very light. Will definitely be stopping in whenever I'm in the area again.

The pizza was amazing and their customer service was great! There was a new worker in today ( never caught his name ) but he was at the register taking orders and he was very polite and made me and my partner feel welcomed! Staff in general are all great as well. Great pizza/service. Overall this is such great gathering place, there were many family’s enjoying themselves so this is definitely a spot to try :)

It was the best sandwich I ever ate !! The pizzas look delicious and are handmade. I recommand a 100% !!

This is what I called a damn good pizza! And the price-height ratio is very good.

Amazing pizza. Great for date nights or casual dining. We had the sausage and onion pizza and it was super tasty. This has become go to pizza place for me. I wouldn't sleep on their baked goods either - the cinnamon buns and apple fritters are especially good

The pizza slices are pretty good, but don't forget to order their donuts! They're made fresh daily and are much better than Krispy Kreme. Fresh, soft, and definitely worth trying.

I was seriously impressed. I had the margherita slice along with an apple cinnamon donut, and both were outstanding. The pizza was fresh, flavourful, and had that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust that puts it right up there with some of Toronto’s best pizza spots.

The real surprise for me was the donut. It was fresh, light, fluffy. Top tier donut. You can tell everything is made with care, and the quality really stands out.

The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, Everything tasted fresh, the service was great.

I’ll absolutely be coming back next time I’m in Toronto.

I was seriously impressed. I had the margherita slice along with an apple cinnamon donut, and both were outstanding. The pizza was fresh, flavourful, and had that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust that puts it right up there with some of Toronto’s best pizza spots.

The real surprise for me was the donut. It was fresh, light, fluffy. Top tier donut. You can tell everything is made with care, and the quality really stands out.

The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, Everything tasted fresh, the service was great.

I’ll absolutely be coming back next time I’m in Toronto.

I've been going here for donuts for a while now (my favourite!!) but have never had the food until today. HIGHLY recommend oh my goodness. We shared an order of breadsticks which were so good. Fantastic marinara sauce 👌 We also split an American Hero sandwich, which was outstanding. The ingredients were super fresh & the meat was incredible quality. We got a pizza & mozzarella sticks to go and I'm so excited so dig in!! And of course, a half dozen donuts. Finally, the staff are so friendly, excellent service and great seats for window watching.

Edit: went back to try the deep dish & deep-fried calzone 👌 the calzone was massive & both were absolutely delicious

I've been going here for donuts for a while now (my favourite!!) but have never had the food until today. HIGHLY recommend oh my goodness. We shared an order of breadsticks which were so good. Fantastic marinara sauce 👌 We also split an American Hero sandwich, which was outstanding. The ingredients were super fresh & the meat was incredible quality. We got a pizza & mozzarella sticks to go and I'm so excited so dig in!! And of course, a half dozen donuts. Finally, the staff are so friendly, excellent service and great seats for window watching.

Edit: went back to try the deep dish & deep-fried calzone 👌 the calzone was massive & both were absolutely delicious

This spot is in a busy part of the Trinity Bellwoods / Dundas West neighborhood and we scored a spot in front of the restaurant! The parking dude told us we can't stay there (oops) but he walked away and said we could have a few minutes and I think he was giving us time to get our eeeats knowing we were chasing a tasty slice from this Toronto pizzeria! As soon as we walked in we were greeted by a wall of donuts and a friendly person who told us about the pizza slices they had. It was legit, charred, saucy, moist and everything you want from a proper slice. Go get one now! 🤩

This spot is in a busy part of the Trinity Bellwoods / Dundas West neighborhood and we scored a spot in front of the restaurant! The parking dude told us we can't stay there (oops) but he walked away and said we could have a few minutes and I think he was giving us time to get our eeeats knowing we were chasing a tasty slice from this Toronto pizzeria! As soon as we walked in we were greeted by a wall of donuts and a friendly person who told us about the pizza slices they had. It was legit, charred, saucy, moist and everything you want from a proper slice. Go get one now! 🤩

Smashing IT!🍩🍕🥰🍕🍩

The Fourth Man in the Fire — Donuts, Pizza, and Pure Happiness!

DONUTS AND PIZZA. CAN YOU ASK FOR ANYTHING MORE?

You absolutely cannot.

All of my dreams came true the moment I discovered this spot—one place serving my two favorite foods, both done to absolute perfection.

As soon as you walk inside this magical haven, you’re greeted by an enormous showcase of freshly baked donuts. They’re out‑of‑this‑world, irresistible, and downright breathtaking. Soft, cushiony, and made fresh on the hour, each donut is a little masterpiece bursting with scrumptious flavor.

And then… there’s the pizza. Whether you’re grabbing a slice or ordering a whole pie, take it from a NEW YORKER: this is the real McCoy. Hands down the best pizza in Toronto. No debate.

Perfect crust thin and crispy, perfect sauce nice and light with a sweet tang, the pepperoni smokey and savory!

The restaurant itself is spacious, welcoming, and perfect for dining in or taking your goodies to go. The customer service is excellent, adding even more charm to an already unforgettable experience.

My taste buds have never been happier.

Nestled in the heart of Dundas Street West—where all the cool and trendy folks hang out—The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria has officially become my favorite place for amazing eats.

What are you waiting for?

YOU GOTTA EAT HERE. Yum!

Smashing IT!🍩🍕🥰🍕🍩

The Fourth Man in the Fire — Donuts, Pizza, and Pure Happiness!

DONUTS AND PIZZA. CAN YOU ASK FOR ANYTHING MORE?

You absolutely cannot.

All of my dreams came true the moment I discovered this spot—one place serving my two favorite foods, both done to absolute perfection.

As soon as you walk inside this magical haven, you’re greeted by an enormous showcase of freshly baked donuts. They’re out‑of‑this‑world, irresistible, and downright breathtaking. Soft, cushiony, and made fresh on the hour, each donut is a little masterpiece bursting with scrumptious flavor.

And then… there’s the pizza. Whether you’re grabbing a slice or ordering a whole pie, take it from a NEW YORKER: this is the real McCoy. Hands down the best pizza in Toronto. No debate.

Perfect crust thin and crispy, perfect sauce nice and light with a sweet tang, the pepperoni smokey and savory!

The restaurant itself is spacious, welcoming, and perfect for dining in or taking your goodies to go. The customer service is excellent, adding even more charm to an already unforgettable experience.

My taste buds have never been happier.

Nestled in the heart of Dundas Street West—where all the cool and trendy folks hang out—The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria has officially become my favorite place for amazing eats.

What are you waiting for?

YOU GOTTA EAT HERE. Yum!

A while back I came across an Instagram reel for this location, and I thought I'd check it out. I walked two kilometers from the Metro Toronto Convention Centre, and it was worth the walk. Much to my delight, Sim, the woman from the reel, was there. I spoke to her and told her about the reel, and I learned that she is the manager and that she was on The Price Is Right with Howie Mandel, where she won big! I've never met a Price Is Right winner before, so that was awesome!

The pizzeria was quite busy, and for good reason—the food is great. The wait wasn't that long, and the atmosphere was buzzing with energy, and the staff was friendly and quick on their feet. The mozzarella sticks were a good way to start my meal. I could have eaten 20 of those. My pizza was superb in every sense of the word and taste. I wanted to finish, but I had to save room for dessert, and the coconut cream pie was delicious!

I had considered having the donuts, but I'll save that for next time. And there will be a next time! If you're in the area, I would highly recommend stopping in; you won't be disappointed! 10/10!

A while back I came across an Instagram reel for this location, and I thought I'd check it out. I walked two kilometers from the Metro Toronto Convention Centre, and it was worth the walk. Much to my delight, Sim, the woman from the reel, was there. I spoke to her and told her about the reel, and I learned that she is the manager and that she was on The Price Is Right with Howie Mandel, where she won big! I've never met a Price Is Right winner before, so that was awesome!

The pizzeria was quite busy, and for good reason—the food is great. The wait wasn't that long, and the atmosphere was buzzing with energy, and the staff was friendly and quick on their feet. The mozzarella sticks were a good way to start my meal. I could have eaten 20 of those. My pizza was superb in every sense of the word and taste. I wanted to finish, but I had to save room for dessert, and the coconut cream pie was delicious!

I had considered having the donuts, but I'll save that for next time. And there will be a next time! If you're in the area, I would highly recommend stopping in; you won't be disappointed! 10/10!

the staff here were so incredibly kind, friendly, and approachable , this is a very good place for families. the chicken parm sandwich was solid , but i might have been expecting a bit more. there was a generous amount of melted, super stringy SLABS of mozzarella which i enjoyed, and the freshness and slight crunch of the soft bread was also great, but the “vodka” sauce was a bit too marinara-like for me — i don’t LOVE the sweetness of the tomato sauce. also, the sandwich completely was completely DRENCHED with the sauce , which would usually be a good thing but it made the texture of the really great bread very soggy. the chicken was good though — a bit thin , but there were two stacked and they weren’t dry at all.

you can also watch them make donuts while you eat which is fun !!

the staff here were so incredibly kind, friendly, and approachable , this is a very good place for families. the chicken parm sandwich was solid , but i might have been expecting a bit more. there was a generous amount of melted, super stringy SLABS of mozzarella which i enjoyed, and the freshness and slight crunch of the soft bread was also great, but the “vodka” sauce was a bit too marinara-like for me — i don’t LOVE the sweetness of the tomato sauce. also, the sandwich completely was completely DRENCHED with the sauce , which would usually be a good thing but it made the texture of the really great bread very soggy. the chicken was good though — a bit thin , but there were two stacked and they weren’t dry at all.

you can also watch them make donuts while you eat which is fun !!